- - “Survivor 49” finale recap: The jury gets it right

Dalton RossDecember 18, 2025 at 4:31 AM

0

Rizo Velovic, Sage Ahrens-Nichols, Kristina Mills, Sophi Balerdi, and Savannah Louie on 'Survivor 49'

“I didn’t come out here to tie any records. I didn’t come out here to make Survivor history in that way. I came out here to be the winner.” — Savannah Louie

And that is why Savannah Louie was crowned the champion of Survivor 49. Here Jeff Probst was, just doing his job asking her to reflect on tying the record for most challenge wins by a woman in Survivor history, probably looking for some spiritual triumph talk and definitely keeping fingers crossed for a few tears, and she basically tossed it back in the host’s face like she was tossing herself to the ground trying to steal MC’s immunity idol.

But Savannah’s hyper-aggressive approach to the game and hyper-focus on victory was more than just a winning formula. It was also a welcome course correction in the kinder, gentler new era of the franchise. She’s out there hovering over MC as the adversary opens her idol. She’s interrogating Kristina about voting plans. She’s talking trash to opponents during endurance challenges.

And just look at the power pose she adopted at Tribal Council — leaning forward, legs spread open — sitting confidentially and attacking the questions from the jury. Her best answer actually came when Jawan asked for her “Why?” This was a big, fat softball thrown right over the middle of the plate for all three finalists — a chance to show off a personal sob story and connect with the jury on a deeply emotional level.

Instead, Savannah rejected the premise of the question. “You don’t have to be the right why in order to be the Sole Survivor. So should my why impact your decision tonight? Honestly, I’m going to say I hope not. And I’m just being real with you.”

2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc.

Savannah Louie on 'Survivor 49'

On the surface, that seems like an absolutely terrible answer. Almost intentionally so. And maybe there was some intent behind it, because by doing so, Savannah actually set herself up as the person that was going to do exactly what every jury asks their finalists to do — be honest and tell it like it is. In showing that she would not just tell the jury what they wanted to hear, the pint-sized powerhouse managed to come off as the most reliable and self-aware narrator in those final three seats.

Should we get into Kristina’s final Tribal question now? Like, I was going to do it later, but should we just go there? Because I think it plays into what Savannah said at the start of this recap, and also how she answered Jawan in the very question before. First off, loved Kristina’s question. Which was not even a question, but rather a request for Savannah to name a family member or partner of everybody on the jury.

I cannot properly express how incredibly awkward the absolute silence that followed Kristina’s request was. “I don’t think I can do it.” Savannah finally responded after doing some quick mental math in her head and coming to the educated conclusion that she was royally screwed.

“I would like for you to try it,” replied Kristina, not letting her target off the hook. God bless you, woman for adding some much needed spice to the proceedings. I mean, Kristina didn’t go full Brenda Lowe or anything. This was not a vindictive question meant to embarrass anyone (although I’m guessing had embarrassment ensued that would not have been an unwelcome development). It actually spoke to Savannah’s social game — or lack thereof — that Kristina was trying to highlight.

So how would the former reporter handle this live grenade tossed onto the Tribal Council set? For a second there, I was legitimately hoping Savannah would just confidentially start blurting out names that were nowhere even close to actual loved one monikers, like Jack Black passing out nicknames to students in School of Rock: Mr. Cool, Spazzy McGree, Brace Face, Fancy Pants, Turkey Sub.

Seriously, as a jury member, that would have earned my vote right there. In the end, I think she only got three (Nate, Steven, and I’m assuming Rizo) correct, and as someone who also has complete name blindness, I can sympathize.

Normally, that would be complete and utter jury death — even if Savannah was able to work in some fun family facts along the way to show that she was not completely clueless — since juries way more often than not vote for the person they feel closest to. But because Savannah had constantly and consistently been open about her singular focus of winning the game, you could almost excuse the lack of genuine connection.

It would be another thing entirely if Savannah had branded herself as a soft and gooey social player there to make bonds with people on this incredible journey of self-discovery. This sort of name game failing would have then been seen as disqualifying under those circumstances. But she never pretended to be that person. Did anyone even expect her to ace that test? If you’re grading on a curve, maybe getting three right was actually a pleasant surprise!

The point is, whether you loved her or loathed her, Savannah always kept it real and on brand, and that had to have helped peel off folks like Alex, Steven, and Sophie, who declined to provide winning votes for their original allies Sophi and Sage.

Sage Ahrens-Nichols on 'Survivor 49'

You all know I have nothing but love for Sage. One of my absolute favorites of any era. Not to get too Probstian, but she’s a person who clearly struggled in her past fitting in before finally embracing her own uniqueness. She was also no mere kooky character sideshow, but a player who was actually heavily involved in strategy talk. Sage played the damn game.

I’m sure Sophi frustrated viewers by constantly talking about making a move against Rizo and Savannah… and then not actually doing it. But with more intel now delivered in my pre-finale interviews with the final five and the jury, it is now clearer that Steven, not Rizo, was the bigger threat to win the game. And Sophi’s lack of action against her ally now looks at least a little better knowing that. She also rebounded well from the Knowledge is Power disaster to win the advantage and the final immunity competition.

But let’s get real: Savannah earned this title. She was the consensus biggest threat when the merge hit, and still made it to the end. She won four immunity challenges. She undeniably played balls to the wall every single second of the game. A very deserving winner, to be sure.

Thought I was finished? To quote Sage: Oh, I’m not done! So let’s recap everything else that went down on the Survivor 49 finale.

Sophi Balerdi, Sage Ahrens-Nichols, Savannah Louie, Kristina Mills and Rizo Velovic on 'Survivor 49'Herstory is made

Things started off a bit rough for the latest victim of the Knowledge is Power curse, as Sophi regretted not stealing Rizo’s idol to fast-pass herself to the final four. “On top of that, I embarrassed myself in front of the jury for no reason,” noted the Silent Assassin.

But things would soon turn around as a boat arrived to kick off the now traditional finale scramble — where contestants run around searching for something to give them a leg up in the first immunity challenge. And the players (at least the ones with shoes on) went all out.

“I know making it to day 24 out of 26 sounds like a huge accomplishment, but 24 out of 26 is not enough for me,” said Savannah in the most Savannah quote imaginable. But while the athletic marvel dominated the physical portion of the advantage hunt — collecting her puzzle piece bags and getting a big head start in the bag search — it was Sophi who finally decided to look up and procured the advantage.

And the advantage allowed her to essentially skip half a stage in the giant obstacle course portion of the first challenge before the puzzle. If she could ever get out of the mud, that is.

Want to be kept up with all things Survivor? Dig deep and sign up for Entertainment Weekly's free Survivor Weekly newsletter to have all the latest news, interviews, and commentary sent right to your inbox.

Honestly, there is no person I enjoy watching struggling in challenges more than Sophi. Not because I necessarily wish her any ill will, but it’s all about her running DVD commentary track along the way. The woman is constantly talking to herself in unintentionally hilarious terms about how poorly she’s doing … which only makes me want her to do even worse! To continue making me laugh! At her expense! It’s like one sidesplitting cycle of incompetent doom. The only thing that could make the entire thing any better is if she had a hat affixed to her head with the words SILENT ASSASSIN custom embroidered on the front. Probst should have put her on season 50 for that reason alone.

Eventually — after a certifiably awesome slow-mo shot of Kristina in the mud followed by two massive and equally entertaining wipe-outs — all the players made it through the obstacle course and onto the platform for the puzzle. “This is where this challenge is going to be won or lost right here,” said Probst, stating the obvious while doing his best Dalton Ross impression.

And the challenge was won by — who else? — Savannah, enabling her to join Kelly Wiglesworth, Jenna Morasca, Kim Spradlin, Chrissy Hofbeck, and Rachel LaMont as the only women to claim four individual immunity challenges in a single season. (Note that all six of those ladies made it to the very end, and four of them won.)

Before moving on, respect to Sophi for walking all the way across the platform to copy Savannah’s puzzle. If producers are going to continue to make it so easy for players to cheat off each other — and they will continue the practice because it makes an exciting comeback more likely — then you would be a fool not to do it. Just ask Rizo!

Sophi Balerdi on 'Survivor 49'A non-united front

I thought Savannah was making a brilliant jury management move by bringing Sage on reward with her. You know, fill her with a nice hearty steak dinner, say your hands are tied on the vote, and bid her au revoir. Only it turns out Savannah didn’t even want her on the jury. At least not yet.

In a very un-Savannah-like move, she said it was actually a bad strategic decision, but on a personal level just wanted to eat dinner with Sage. Instead, she wanted Kristina out. Now, to the viewers, this seemed Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs, as the edit has painted Kristina as exactly the person you want to be sitting next to at the end.

However, there is one thing the edit has not shown us: Kristina apparently takes to fire like Michael Skupin’s hands. So if she ended up in a fire-making competition, whoever was sitting next to her would be in deeper trouble than Rizo’s awful facial hair situation. Savannah wanted no part of that, which is to say she wanted no part of Rizo’s awful facial hair situation or taking on Kristina in fire.

But The Man The Myth The Legend R-I-Z-G-O-D RizGod baby wanted Kristina around because he saw her as easily beatable at the end. And Soph appeared to be leaning that way as well, especially after talking to Sage. “The more that Sage talks to me, the less I want to keep her,” Blue Sophi noted. “She’s very strategic. She’s thinking way more than Kristina is.… She’s not a very strategic player.” Harsh.

It was then off to Tirbal Council to see which way it would go, and if Kristina would finally get to eat a real plate of spaghetti with her hands as opposed to a metaphorical one.

Robert Voets/CBS

Kristina Mills on 'Survivor 49'End of an idol

Now I realize what I am about to say is impacted strongly by the newly uncovered knowledge of Kristina’s secret fire-making skills. But even so. Even with the threat of Kristina mastering and handling fire not unlike the Human Torch, I have to tell you that when the ultimate showman Rizo walked up to Probst at the final five Tribal Council to finally play his Beware Advantage Idol, every fiber of my being was daring to dream that he would say the following words…

“Jeff, let’s have a little fun. You know, I’ve had this pretty baby for a while now. Have managed to fool some people now on the jury with it. Some may say it’s the best use of an idol by the best player this game has ever seen. That’s not for me to say, but other people may be saying it. Probably saying it, in fact, if I had to venture a guess. Accurately, too, I might add. But since this is the last time this bad boy can be used, it’s time to finally play it. And play it, I shall. Jeff, I would like to play this immunity idol… for Kristina.”

Can you imagine? Think about the look on Kristina’s face. Think about the look on Savannah and Sophi’s faces as he just negated the two votes of his biggest allies to wrest complete control over the elimination. Think about the faces on the jury! My main man Jawan — who has somehow transformed into a male juror version of Eliza Orlins with his constant exaggerated facial expressions and wild gesticulating — would have positively LOST HIS MIND!

Would it have made any sense? With Kristina’s fire-making skills, probably not. BUT IT WOULD HAVE BEEN CINEMA!!!!! You want to go down as a true icon of the game, then make like Montell Jordan, because this is how you do it.

Anyway, that sadly did not happen. Instead, we got Sage and Kristina arguing why they were the easier person to beat at the end and thereby more worth keeping. This is such a fascinatingly tricky spot when you get into these last few Tribal Councils and have to somehow thread the proverbial needle to convince the other players deciding your fate that you are no threat to win… while also not completely denigrating your own game in front of the jury, who could be deciding your Survivor take-home pay in 48 hours.

In the end, Kristina was cut loose, and the tribe just kind of sat there silent and awkward as she went to go retrieve her torch before hugging her uncle. Unfortunately, she did not take Rizo’s torch, and it still makes me mad that every post-Jawan person voted out did not do this because it would have been the funniest thing in Survivor history.

Kristina Mills, Sage Ahrens-Nichols, and Sophi Balerdi on 'Survivor 49'Worst to first

“Soph, once again dead last.”

That’s Probst during the final immunity challenge of the season — another obstacle course, this one leading to a table puzzle that needed to be put together and then used to get two balls into two holes. (Insert your own jokes here. And then insert your own jokes over the use of the word “insert.”)

Once again, Sophi was struggling, and once again her pain was our gain as she provided some classic play-by-play on her lack of success. And then… up became down! Black became white! Yin became yang! Dogs became cats! (Strike that last one. That sounds scary.) The point is, Sophi came from nowhere (well… last place) to suddenly catch up, put her puzzle track together in less time than it took me to write this sentence (which, granted, is becoming a longer sentence by the word) and then sunk both balls before anyone else had landed one.

She didn’t just come back and squeak out a win, she flat out dominated those fools. S-O-P-H-G-O-D! And The Women The Myth The Legend was feeling herself, suddenly making like my gal Shannon in our pregame interview and being unable to stop talking. “I earned my spot to the final three,” she told the host. “Now I feel like I really do have a shot to win this!” (Hold your horses there, my friend).

While that may have sounded like an overzealous assessment, had RizGod been able to lord over fire, then there’s a very strong chance your Survivor 49 winner is named Sophi. Or Blue Sophi. Or Soph. (PLEASE STOP CASTING PEOPLE WITH THE SAME NAME IN THE SAME SEASON!!!)

But she was right about one thing in her elated state. She will always have that moment. To be a massive fan of the show and then not only have Probst put an immunity necklace around your neck, but to do it at the final immunity challenge — that’s straight-up awesome. And it’s nice Sophi got to have that moment, especially after the Silent Assassin was very loudly murdered in front of way too many witnesses at the final six Tribal Council.

Sophi Balerdi and Rizo Velovic on 'Survivor 49'Rizo gets burned

My favorite part of the entire episode may have been when the final four returned to camp after the challenge and Sophi told the others that she didn’t know what she wanted to do… yet there was also nothing they could say to convince her. (???) I’m not quite sure how that all adds up, but what I do know is that Savannah was not pleased. Not only was her bestie potentially not taking her to the end, but she was also not allowed to even pitch her case. “It feels like I’m getting screwed over,” she told us. “Is this the real Soph? It feels like I didn’t know my best friend out here.” (Best friend? Quick: What’s her fiancé’s name?)

The mystery over who Sophi would put into fire continued right into Tribal Council, where Probst appeared to suggest that Sophi might want to think about putting herself in by noting that Chrissy didn’t (and lost) and Chris Underwood did (and won). Alas, the host neglected to mention that Chris Underwood spent 27 of his 39 days on the Edge of Extinction bonding with the jury against the people that voted them out, but we’ll let that slide.

“I came to not win second or third place,” Sophi announced while making her decision. “I came to win it, and for me, that means putting my two allies to fire tonight.” Guess what? Turns out you can do both!

Props to Rizo for embracing the fire battle and props to Savannah for once again showing her complete honesty: “While Rizo is excited to make fire, I would gladly sit this one out.” And props to Sage for capping her pants on national television.

2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc.

Rizo Velovic on 'Survivor 49'

As much as I am not a fan of the fire-making contest for many reasons I have repeated way too many times already, it has undeniably given us some epic moments of nail-biting television. This was not one of those moments. Savannah destroyed him. It was a straight-up massacre.

And thus ended the RizGod’s super entertaining run. It can be really grating and annoying when people get on TV just to be a “character,” but the thing about Rizo is that he wasn’t only there to create theater. He was an actual gamer — and a good one. Look at the way he worked the margins to influence votes like taking out MC instead of Yellow Sophie, and shifting the target to Alex. That’s top-tier stuff.

I remember going to his tribe camp on day 2 of the game, and after he went big in our pre-game interview I expected to see this huge personality eating up all the oxygen, but he was totally restrained. He was even asked directly by tribemates if he had any Riz nicknames and completely brushed it off. Which is what makes his exit so interesting. Because he specifically asked Probst to call him by his nickname. Yet at far as what made it to screen, the host had never heard Rizo’s nickname uttered, meaning he should not have been able to say it on screen.

Make no mistake, Probst knew the nickname. Rizo no doubt said it in casting 5,628,397 times. But in terms of what Probst “knows” on the show, it has to be something that is told to him by contestants. That’s why on day 1 he’ll say stuff like “You, purple tank-top in the back. What’s your name?” even though he’s already met the dude and memorized his name. It’s why he’ll ask at a challenge, “There was an advantage back at camp. What happened there?” even though he knows damn well what happened.

For him to “know” this information on screen, you have to tell him. But we never saw Rizo mention it. Anyway, I just went three paragraphs deep on that for no reason other than my own obsession with Survivor minutia, but if you’re already 3,300 words into this thing, you know what you signed up for.

Rizo Velovic on 'Survivor 49'More final Tribal Council thoughts

We’re going to skip right over all of day 26 and just get right to final Tribal Council because it’s not worth reading too much into that package of the final three having to talk up their own games, or jurors being forced to explain why each person could win the game so producers can edit it in such a way that it looks like it’s anybody’s game. Never read too much into those. (This season showed Steven and Alex talking up Sophi and Kristina hyping Sage. Enough said.)

We’ve already gotten into a lot of this final Tribal already, but the first big headline was that we had our first all-female final three in 20 seasons (since Survivor: San Jaun del Sur). That’s a long time and seems like a huge accomplishment. (Probably best to not mention that the last all-male final three drought is even longer, as you have to go all the way back to season 21, Survivor: Nicaragua, to when a dude named Fabio beat another dude named Sash… as well country music superstar Chase Rice. There was also an all-male final two 21 seasons ago for Cagayan.)

The other big headline is that while Kristina served up big-time deliciousness with her name-a-family-member gotcha moment, and a few jurors pushed back on Sage when she took credit for moves that everyone didn’t seem to agree with, it was a very tame and drama free jury Q&A. Not even Rizo came to play. Instead of packing heat, The Man The Myth The Legend shared affirmations for all three finalists. Affirmations??? Know your brand, R-I-Z-G-O-D!

To be clear, I’m not looking for people to be mean (well, maybe a little) but a little spice is always nice instead of just back patting and talking about their inspirations and journeys. I am a big Jawan guy, but I honestly could not care less about their why in that moment.

Sophi Balerdi and Savannah Louie on 'Survivor 49'

What I did enjoy is seeing Savannah and Sophi battle each other a bit up there. When Savannah was struggling to come up with family member names, you saw Sophi mouthing the names to prove that she did know them. (Smart.) And when Savannah told MC that her big move of influencing a vote was getting her allies to take out Kristina, Sophi countered that it was an emotional and not a strategic decision. Savannah then punched back by noting that she was “loyal to the soil” (totally stealing that, by the way) and that she never would have put her two allies into fire like Sophi did.

It was all very respectful, but they were battling and you love to see it. Meanwhile, Sage was battling something else: a jury that was not picking up what she was putting down. She argued that her best move was turning on Sophie, only to have Sophie shoot back, “Didn’t everybody vote for me?” And her former ally Steven seemed super unimpressed when Sage answered his question about voting out all her allies except Jawan.

Whether this was a severe case of BJS (Bitter Jury Syndrome) or Sage just didn’t have the strategic chops is probably in the eye of the beholder. I will just say that I believe Sage walked into that Tribal Council believing she had a legitimate shot to win the $1 million. To find out in real time that the jury does not see you the way you thought you were being seen is a really tough pill to swallow. (And the fact you then have to swallow that pill with champagne at a celebratory After-Show while processing your rejection is borderline cruel.)

I don’t think Sage always made the right strategic moves, but she was making moves! She was playing the game. Not only that, but she was doing so while also being a freaky misfit, and there is nothing I love more on planet Earth than freaky misfits. I’m so glad Sage was on the cast and part of this season, and I sincerely hope she can be proud of remaining true to herself while making it all the way to the end without ever being voted out. Not easy, folks.

Sage Ahrens-Nichols on 'Survivor 49'

As for the after-show, the highlight (other than Jawan overfilling his champagne glass) had to be Jeff listing all the idols and advantages that were played incorrectly or unnecessarily. I never really put it together what a run of idol and advantage futility that was until he listed it off. Although I’ll admit to being a bit distracted throughout the whole thing worrying that Sage was doing okay. I’ve said it before that I think it’s borderline cruel to put someone who was just rejected by their peers immediately into a champagne party. And previous losing finalists have expressed how terrible it is having to do it.

Sage was clearly hurting. “It’s hard to separate emotion from game, but it kills me to think I might have hurt people,” she said through tears. Even harder to hear was Sage saying she thought she did not even merit the sympathy people were giving her. Just brutal. I'm hoping time has healed some of those wounds.

So, look… greatest season ever? No. The pre-merge problems have been widely documented, and while things certainly picked up thanks to some surprising flips and post-merge votes, the finale lacked any true fireworks or jaw-dropping moments. At least we got a deserving champion. I really do believe when this season is looked back upon years down the line, Savannah is going to be seen as a strong winner. Did she have any flashy moves? No. But she showed that a socially and physically aggressive game could succeed, and that is something every fan should favor.

Okay, time to wrap this up. A reminder that we have tons more final coverage to go, including an exclusive deleted scene, word from Probst himself, interviews with the final five, your first look at Survivor 50, season rankings, and more.

It should also be noted that we will have MOUNTAINS of Survivor 50 coverage, so make sure to sign up now for our free Survivor newsletter so you don’t miss out on any of the goodness.

Thanks to everyone for once again playing along for all this nonsense. I’ve now been writing about Survivor for 49 seasons, which I believe makes me clinically insane, but I appreciate you coming along for the ride. Have an amazing holiday, and I’ll be back soon with a 2026 scoop of the crispy!

on Entertainment Weekly

Original Article on Source

Source: “AOL Entertainment”